The short answer
A donation page that works has three jobs, in this order:
- Let a decided donor finish fast. Few clicks, few fields, mobile wallets, no surprises.
- Reassure an undecided one. What the gift does, who you are, and where the money goes.
- Ask for the next thing. Monthly instead of once, a match from their employer, a share.
Most nonprofit sites already have the stories and photos that make people want to give. Where they lose gifts is the last step: the button that's hard to find, the page that sends people somewhere else, the form with fourteen fields. That's the part this guide fixes. If you want to see the whole site side, our pages on nonprofit web design and animal rescue web design cover it.
Fewer clicks between wanting to give and giving
Count the taps on your own site, on your phone, from the home page to a finished gift. Every tap, page load and field is a chance for someone to get distracted by a text and never come back.
Worked example: counting taps
A typical setup we see: home page, tap Donate in the menu, land on a page about giving, scroll, tap a button, get sent to a platform's page, pick an amount, tap next, type name, email, address and phone, tap next, type the card, tap give. That's ten or more steps across two sites. The tighter version: tap Donate in the header, land on the form with an amount already selected, tap Apple Pay or Google Pay, confirm. Four steps, one site. Same donor, same intent, far fewer places to drop off.
How to cut the steps:
- Put Donate in the header on every page, styled as a button, and keep it visible on phones.
- Send that button straight to the form. The story can sit beside or below the form; it shouldn't stand in front of it.
- Preselect an amount so the first tap is optional.
- Ask only what you need. Name, email and payment. Ask for a mailing address only if you really mail donors.
- Offer mobile wallets. On a phone, Apple Pay or Google Pay skips typing a card number entirely.

Embedded donation forms vs Stripe on your own site
There are three common ways to take gifts online. All three can work well. The right one depends on how much you raise online, how much web help you have, and how much you care about the page feeling like yours.
| Hosted donation page | Embedded third-party form | Stripe on your own site | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the donor gives | On the platform's site, after a click away from yours | On your page, inside the platform's form | On your page, in your own form |
| Setup | Fastest. Sign up and share a link | Fast. Paste their code into your page | Needs a developer to build and keep up |
| What it costs | Card processing, plus any platform fee or optional donor tip, per their pricing | Same as hosted, since it's their form | Stripe's standard rate of 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card gift, no monthly fee |
| Look and feel | Their branding around yours | Mostly theirs, inside your page | Entirely yours |
| Monthly giving | Usually built in | Usually built in | Built with Stripe subscriptions |
| Tracking in GA4 | Hardest. The gift happens on their site | Often limited, the form sits in a frame | Straightforward. You control the thank-you page |
| Donor data | Lives in their system, exportable | Lives in their system, exportable | Lives in your Stripe account |
| Best for | Small groups, one-off campaigns, no web help | A decent site that needs giving added quickly | Organizations raising steadily online who want it to feel like theirs |
Stripe rate from stripe.com/pricing, checked November 2026: standard rate for domestic cards, with extra for manually entered, international or converted cards. Hosted and embedded platforms each set their own fees, so read their pricing pages before you compare.
Fees deserve a careful look, because the difference between options is often the fees, not the features. With Stripe's standard rate of 2.9% + 30¢, a $50 card gift costs $1.75 to process, so $48.25 reaches you. A $100 gift costs $3.20. A hosted platform charges the card processing plus whatever its own model is: some add a platform percentage, some ask the donor for an optional tip instead. Work out what each option keeps from a $50 gift and a $20 monthly gift over a year, then decide.
Whichever you pick, an option for donors to cover the processing fee is worth adding. Many will tick it.
Animal rescues have one more option. RescueGroups.org, a nonprofit platform many rescues already use for listings, offers its pet adoption portal free, a website service at $100 a year, online forms at $59 a year and data management at $75 a year (rescuegroups.org/services, checked November 2026). For a small rescue without web help, that's a sensible, low-cost place to start, with a donate button out to a processor. If you already run on Shelterluv, your adoptable animals can feed your own site directly; see Shelterluv website integration.
One-time and monthly giving
A monthly donor is worth far more than a single gift, and costs you nothing to ask. Put a clear one-time or monthly choice at the top of the form, and make monthly easy to pick without hiding the one-time option.
- Show monthly in monthly terms. "$20 a month" next to what that covers in a year, from your own costs.
- Give monthly donors a name if you like (a circle, a club), but don't make it a hurdle.
- Let them manage it themselves. A link to update a card or cancel. Stripe has a hosted customer portal for exactly this, and an easy cancel makes people more willing to start.
- Thank them every so often with something real: a photo, an update, a number you can stand behind.
On fees, monthly gifts are small and frequent, so the fixed part of the card fee matters more. A $20 monthly gift at Stripe's standard rate costs $0.88 each month to process, $10.56 over a year. Still well worth it, and another reason to offer the cover-the-fee option.
Suggested amounts that say what they fund
Suggested amounts help people decide. Amounts that say what they do help even more. The catch: the impact line has to be true for your organization, from your own numbers. Don't borrow another group's figures.
| Suggested amount | What it funds (fill in from your own costs) | Where the number comes from |
|---|---|---|
| A small amount, like $25 | One thing you buy often, e.g. a week of food for one foster, a meal kit | Your last few receipts for that item |
| A middle amount, like $50 | A routine cost, e.g. one round of vaccines, one tutoring session | Your average invoice for it |
| A larger amount, like $100 | A bigger single cost, e.g. a spay or neuter, a month of a program | Your vet or vendor's usual bill |
| Monthly, like $20/mo | Something ongoing, e.g. a foster's supplies all year | Twelve months of that cost |
| Other | Let them type any amount | Never take this option away |
The dollar amounts are placeholders. The middle column is yours to fill in from real receipts. If a gift isn't restricted to that item, say "helps cover" rather than "pays for".
A few rules. Round to amounts people recognize. Keep it to three or four choices plus Other. Check the lines once a year, since costs move. And be careful with wording. If a gift goes into your general fund, "$50 helps cover a round of vaccines" is honest; "$50 buys a vaccine" can imply the gift is restricted to that use, which your accountant may want handled differently.
Employer matching, wish lists and fundraisers
Employer matching
Many employers match their staff's gifts, and many donors never ask. A short matching section on your donation page and thank-you page changes that. Tell donors to check with their HR or giving portal, and list what the employer will ask for: your legal name, your EIN, your address and a contact for verification. Some employers also give grants for volunteer hours, so mention that on your volunteer page too.
Wish lists
Some supporters would rather buy a thing than give cash. A wish list (many rescues use Amazon or Chewy) gives them that, and the item ships straight to you. Link it from the donation page as a second option, not the first, and keep it current.
Fundraisers and events
Peer fundraisers, birthday fundraisers and events all bring new people in. Wherever the money is collected, give every campaign a page on your own site that explains the cause and links to the donation page, so new supporters land somewhere they can come back to. Use tagged links from our free UTM Link Builder so you can see which campaign sent each visitor.
Receipts and the thank-you page
The receipt is part of the gift. Send it automatically, the moment the gift goes through, and get the wording right:
- Your legal name and EIN, the amount and the date.
- Whether anything was given in return. If the donor got a T-shirt or a dinner, the receipt should say so and give its value.
- A statement your accountant approves. The IRS requires a written acknowledgment for any single gift of $250 or more before the donor can deduct it, so the wording matters.
- For monthly donors, a year-end summary as well as each month's receipt.
Then the thank-you page. Most organizations waste it on a plain "Thank you". Say thanks like a person, tell them what happens next (the receipt email, when you'll update them), and offer exactly one next step: make it monthly, check for an employer match, share the page, or sign up to volunteer. One, not four.
The thank-you page is also where you count the gift, which comes next.
Trust signals: your status and where the money goes
A first-time donor wants to know you're real and you'll use the money well. Show them, near the form:
- Your legal name and status. "[Legal name] is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit. EIN [number]. Gifts are tax-deductible as allowed by law." Donors can check you in the IRS's tax-exempt organization search.
- Where the money goes, in a sentence or two, in your words. Then link to your annual report or financials for anyone who wants the detail. Don't print a percentage you can't show.
- Real photos of your animals, programs or people you serve, with permission.
- A way to reach a person: an email or phone number for questions about giving.
- The basics done right: HTTPS, a privacy policy that says what you do with donor data (our free Privacy Policy Generator is a starting point), and a form that looks like it belongs to you.
Track every gift as a GA4 key event
If you don't count gifts, you can't tell which campaign, page or post brought them in. Google Analytics 4 calls the actions you care about key events. Make a completed donation one of them.
- Fire an event when a gift completes, usually when the thank-you page loads after a successful payment, never when someone just clicks Donate.
- Send the value with it, so GA4 can show money raised, not just a count.
- Tag one-time vs monthly as a parameter, so you can see each separately.
- Mark the event as a key event in GA4's admin.
- Test it with a real small gift, then refund it.
This is easiest when the gift happens on your own site. With a hosted page or an embedded form, the payment happens on someone else's system, so check what tracking that platform supports before you choose. Our GA4 basics guide walks through setup, and forms and lead tracking covers counting volunteer and foster sign-ups the same way.
Google Ad Grants: free search ads, if you can track them
Google's Ad Grants program gives eligible nonprofits up to $10,000 a month in ads on Google Search (Google for Nonprofits, checked November 2026). For a lot of small organizations that's the biggest free marketing budget they'll ever get. Two things to know first:
- Tracking comes first. The program's policies require conversion tracking on grant accounts, meaning you count things like donations or volunteer sign-ups. Set up your GA4 key events before you apply, not after. Read the current policy page when you apply, because Google updates the rules.
- The ads need somewhere good to go. Search ads send people to specific pages: adopt, foster, volunteer, donate. Each needs real content and a clear next step.
Eligibility runs through Google for Nonprofits, and Google's page sets out who qualifies. For how paid search fits with getting found for free, see Google Ads vs SEO.
A real example: Rescue Network
A real example
Rescue Network is a foster-based dog and cat rescue in Buffalo. Its site takes Stripe donations on the site itself, with monthly giving and an employer matching section. Every adoptable animal gets its own page, pulled from Shelterluv through its API, so the animals and the donate button live on the same site. A merch store, foster and volunteer intake forms, events run through RunSignup, and an AI assistant that answers common questions from the rescue's own content round it out. The point for this guide: the donor never has to leave the rescue's site to give.
The donation page checklist
Donation page checklist
- A Donate button in the header on every page, including on phones
- The donation page is one page: amount, details, pay
- Card, Apple Pay and Google Pay where your processor supports them
- One-time and monthly, with monthly easy to pick
- Three or four suggested amounts that each say what they help fund, plus Other
- An option for donors to cover the processing fee
- Your legal name, 501(c)(3) status and EIN on the page
- A plain line on where the money goes, with a link to your financials
- An employer matching section with the details a donor's employer will ask for
- A receipt email with the wording your accountant approves
- A thank-you page with one next step
- The gift counted as a GA4 key event, with its value
- A way for monthly donors to update a card or cancel without emailing you
You don't need all of it at once. Fix the header button, the click count and the receipt first. Add monthly, matching and tracking next.
On our plans, payments on your own site, donations included, are part of the Growth build at $6,400 plus $349/mo, and sites taking payments stay on a care plan. A smaller site can link cleanly to a hosted form you already use. See the pricing page, or send us your donation page and we'll tell you what we'd change first.
Want a straight answer for your business?
Every Stonekept build is custom-coded, hosted on Cloudflare and kept on a monthly plan. Prices are public: builds from $2,200 with care from $199/mo. See pricing or tell us about your project and we'll give you an honest read, even if that's not us.
