Home/Guides/Choosing a designer
Hiring guide

How to choose a
web designer.

Pick the designer whose answers you understand and can get in writing, not the one with the best sales pitch. The most important answer is what happens if you leave. This guide gives you the questions to ask, what good and bad answers sound like, how to check a portfolio and references, and what a proposal should include.

Updated November 2026 · 15 min read

Two people at a table with coffee and a laptop, talking through a project
Photo: Kampus Production / Pexels

The short answer

Most people choose a web designer by looking at a portfolio and comparing two or three prices. That catches about half of what matters. The other half is in the paperwork: who owns what, what changes cost, and what happens when you leave.

If you only ask one question, ask this one, in writing:

The one question

“If I cancel, does my website stay online, and do I get the files?”

A plain yes tells you that you own the site. A plain no tells you that you're renting it, which can be fine if the price reflects that. A vague answer, or one that talks about your domain and content instead of the site itself, is the answer to watch for.

We explain why this question decides so much on our rent vs own page. The rest of this guide covers the other questions worth asking, how to read the answers, and how to check that a designer can actually do the work.

Freelancer, agency, builder or studio

There are four common ways to get a small business website built, and each one is the right call for someone. The questions in this guide work for all of them.

Usually good forWatch for
A DIY builder (Wix, Squarespace)A new business with a few pages, more time than budget, and someone who enjoys doing itYour time, and a site that only runs on that platform
A freelancerA defined project at a fair price, working with one person who knows your siteWhat happens if they get busy, change careers or move on
A local or national agencyA bigger program: site, ads, search and reporting managed by a teamLong contracts, and how much of the monthly fee is the website
A small studio on a monthly plan (like us)A site built and looked after by the same people, with changes made for youWhether you own the site, and what the monthly plan includes

These are tendencies, not rules. A good freelancer can outlast an agency, and a good agency can be very flexible. Judge the person in front of you on their answers.

If you're not sure a designer is even the right move yet, our Wix vs Squarespace vs WordPress vs custom comparison covers when building it yourself is the better answer. If cost is the first question, start with what a website costs in Minnesota and come back here.

Who should own the domain, hosting, files and content

"You own your website" can mean four different things, and a designer can honestly say it while meaning only one of them. Ask about each one separately.

The domain

Your domain (yourbusiness.com) is the most valuable piece, because your email, your Google profile, your printed cards and every link to your site point at it. It should be registered in your name, or your business's name, in an account you can log in to. A domain typically costs about $15 a year, so there's no money reason to let someone else hold it. If a designer registers it in their own account "to make it easier", ask them to transfer it to you, or set it up yourself and give them access. We go into detail on this in our guide to owning your domain, hosting and email.

The hosting account

Hosting is where the site files live. Plenty of good designers host sites for their clients, and that's often simpler for you. The question isn't whose servers they are. It's whether you can take the site somewhere else if you need to. If the hosting is theirs, the contract should say the files come with you when you go.

The site files

This is the part people miss. The site files are the actual website: the pages, the code, the images in the form the site uses them. On a WordPress site that means the files and the database. On a custom-coded site it's the HTML, CSS and images. On a Wix or Squarespace site there are no files you can take: the site only exists inside that platform. Squarespace, for example, exports only certain content, to a file meant for WordPress, and store pages, portfolios and some blocks don't come across (checked November 2026).

Your content

Your words, photos, logo and reviews. These should be yours no matter what. Keep your own copy of the final text and original photos anyway: if you ever rebuild, that folder saves weeks.

What about the design itself? It's normal for a designer to reuse their own tools, code patterns and know-how on other projects. What you need is the right to keep using, changing and moving your site forever once it's paid for. If the contract says something different, ask what it means in practice before you sign.

Contract traps to read for

None of these means a designer is dishonest. Some are just old habits. But each can cost you real money later, so ask about them before you sign.

A hand signing a printed agreement with a pen
Read the cancellation and ownership clauses before the price. Photo: Pixabay / Pexels
  • The site comes down when you cancel. Common with rented sites. It isn't wrong, but you should know it going in, and the price should reflect it. Ask: "If I stop paying, what's online the next day?"
  • Auto-renewing multi-year terms. A 24 or 36 month contract that renews itself unless you cancel inside a short window, often 30 to 60 days before the end. Ask for the exit cost in writing, and put the cancellation window on your calendar the day you sign.
  • The designer registers the domain in their own name. Usually done for convenience, sometimes used as leverage later. Ask for it in your name from day one.
  • Hourly change fees with no estimate. "Changes are billed at our hourly rate" with no estimate before the work means you can't budget. Ask for a written estimate on anything billable, and a rough price for common jobs: a text edit, a new page, a new photo.
  • No export. No way to take the site with you, or an export that only covers some of it. Ask exactly what you'd receive: files, a database, or a document of your content.
  • "We own the design." If it means they can reuse their own code, that's normal. If it means you can't take your site to another host, or need permission to change it, that's a problem. Ask for plain language: you can use, change and move your site once it's paid for.
  • Hosting tied to marketing. Some packages bundle the site with ads or search work, so cancelling the marketing ends the site. Ask what happens to the site if you stop the other services.

If anything in a contract worries you and the designer can't explain it in plain words, have a lawyer look at it. A good designer won't mind.

The questions to ask, and what the answers mean

Ask every designer you're considering the same questions, ideally by email so the answers are written down. Here's what a good answer and a red flag sound like for each one.

Ask thisA good answerA red flag
If I cancel, does my website stay online, and do I get the files?Yes. You get the full site files, and we'll help you move them to a new host.Talk about your domain or content instead of the site. Or "you can rebuild it anywhere".
Whose name is the domain registered in?Yours, in an account you can log in to. We just need access to point it.Ours, "to make it easier". Or they don't know.
Where is the site hosted, and whose account is it?Named host, and either your account or a plan with a clear exit."Our servers", with no way to take the site with you.
What does a change cost after launch?A clear rule: included in a plan, or a written estimate before any billable work."Just our hourly rate" with no estimate and no cap.
What's the full price, and what isn't included?A fixed number with a written list of what's in and out.A range that "depends", with nothing written down.
How long is the contract, and how do I get out?Month to month, or a fixed term with the exit cost stated up front.A multi-year term that renews itself unless you cancel in a narrow window.
Who writes the words and supplies the photos?A plain split: you bring the facts, they shape them, or they write it all for a stated price.Silence on content, then a launch that waits months for text.
What happens to my Google rankings if I'm redesigning?A list of every old URL, a redirect for each one, and checks after launch."Google will figure it out."
Can I talk to two clients you've built for?Names and contact details, or an offer to connect you.Testimonials only, with no way to reach a real person.
Who will actually build my site?A named role or person, and who you'll talk to day to day.Vague, or the work is passed to people you'll never speak to, without saying so.

Get the answers in writing, in the proposal or contract, not just on a call. A good answer you can't find on paper later is worth very little.

One weak answer doesn't rule anyone out. A designer who says "good question, let me check and put it in the proposal" is fine. The pattern to watch for is a designer who gets vague every time the question is about leaving, owning or paying.

How to check a portfolio properly

A portfolio page shows you screenshots chosen by the designer. That tells you about taste. It doesn't tell you whether the sites work. Here's how to check in about twenty minutes.

  1. Open the live sites, not the screenshots. Ask for links if they're not given. A designer with real clients will have live sites to show. If several portfolio sites are gone or have been replaced, ask why: clients do move on, but you want to hear the story.
  2. Open them on your phone. Most of your customers will see your site on a phone. Can you read it without zooming? Is the phone number one tap away? Does the menu work with a thumb?
  3. Speed test two or three of them. Paste the address into our free Website Speed Test, which runs Google PageSpeed Insights. Google's own targets for a good page are the main content showing within 2.5 seconds, responses to taps within 200 milliseconds, and very little layout shift (web.dev Core Web Vitals). A mobile score that's consistently poor across a designer's work is worth asking about.
  4. Check the details. Fill in a contact form and see if the page handles it cleanly. Look for a real address and service area, clear page titles in the browser tab, and no broken images.
  5. Look for businesses like yours. Not the same trade necessarily, but the same kind of job. A contractor needs service pages, town pages and quote requests. A restaurant needs a menu and hours that are easy to update. A designer who's solved your problem before will ask better questions.
  6. Ask what they did and didn't do. On a portfolio site, did they write the copy, take the photos, set up the Google profile? Or just the design? That tells you what you'd be getting.
Two hands holding a phone
Check every portfolio site on your phone first. That's where your customers will be. Photo: MART PRODUCTION / Pexels

Be fair about speed scores. Results vary from run to run, and a client's own widgets can drag a score down. Look for a pattern, not one number.

References: who to call and what to ask

Testimonials on a website are chosen by the designer. A ten-minute call with a real client is worth more than all of them. Ask for two clients, ideally one recent and one who's been with the designer for a year or more.

Questions that get useful answers:

  • Did the project finish when they said it would? If not, why not?
  • Was the final price the quoted price?
  • When you need a change now, how long does it take and what does it cost?
  • Do you know who owns your domain and where your site is hosted?
  • Has anything gone wrong, and how did they handle it?
  • Would you hire them again?

The "something went wrong" question is the best one. Every project has a bump. You want to hear that the designer said so early and fixed it. Be fair, too: a launch that slipped because content was late isn't the designer's fault.

What a good proposal includes

A proposal is where the answers to your questions should end up. If something was promised on a call and isn't in the proposal, ask for it to be added. Here's what to look for:

What a good proposal includes

  • A fixed price, or a clear estimate with a cap, and the payment schedule
  • The page list: which pages, how many, and what counts as a page
  • Who writes the copy and who supplies the photos, and what it costs if they do
  • What's included for search: page titles, descriptions, structured data, a sitemap, the Google Business Profile
  • Hosting: where, whose account, and the cost in year two and three
  • The domain: registered in your name, in an account you can reach
  • Ownership: you own the domain, your content and the site files when it's paid for
  • What happens if you cancel: the site stays up, you get the files, and how long the handover takes
  • The change policy after launch: included, or estimated in writing before work starts
  • How many design rounds, and what happens if you don't like the direction
  • A timeline with the things you need to supply and when
  • For a redesign: the redirect plan for every old URL

Two clear pages can cover all of this. The test: could you hand it to someone else in a year and they'd understand exactly what you bought?

Worked example

A landscaping company in Otsego gets three quotes for a ten-page site with service pages and a few town pages.

  • Quote A is the cheapest upfront. The fine print says the domain is registered by the designer, hosting is theirs, and the site is "licensed" to the client while the hosting is paid. Changes are hourly with no estimate.
  • Quote B is in the middle. It's a fixed price, the domain stays in the client's name, and there's a 36-month hosting and maintenance term that renews automatically unless cancelled 60 days before the end.
  • Quote C is the most expensive upfront. It's a fixed price with a page list, a monthly plan that's month to month, and a line that says the client gets the site files if they cancel.

The owner asks each one the one question. A says the site would come down but they could "rebuild it elsewhere". B says the files are the client's, but the term still has to be paid out. C says yes. Now the comparison is clear: A is the cheapest only for as long as they stay, B is fine if they're sure about three years and put the renewal date on the calendar, C costs more today but has the cheapest way out. Which is right depends on the owner, but at least they're comparing the real thing.

Things that look like red flags but aren't

Being careful is good. Being suspicious of everything slows you down and can push you toward the designer who simply promises the most. These are normal:

  • A deposit. Most designers take part of the fee upfront, often half. That's standard. What you want to know is what you get for it and when the rest is due.
  • A monthly fee. Every website needs hosting, a domain and upkeep. A monthly plan isn't a trap. A monthly plan you can never leave without losing the site might be.
  • "We don't guarantee rankings." That's honest. Nobody controls Google's results, and Google says itself there's no way to pay for a better local ranking. Be more wary of the designer who does guarantee first place.
  • Saying no to part of your plan. A designer who tells you a feature isn't worth it, or that a builder would suit you better, is usually looking out for you.

How we answer these questions

It's only fair to answer our own list. Here's where we stand, and you can check all of it on our pricing page.

  • If you cancel: the site files are yours, and we help you move them. Your domain and content were always yours.
  • The domain: registered in your name. We just point it at the site.
  • Price: fixed and published. Builds run from $2,200 to $6,400, with care plans from $199 to $349 a month, or the $79 hand-off plan for a Launch or Standard site that just needs keeping online.
  • Payment: 50% to start and the rest at launch. Before the balance is due, we design your home page and one key inner page. If you don't like the direction, your deposit comes back in full.
  • Contract: month to month by default. The optional 12-month care term lowers the build price, and if you leave early you pay back part of the discount, never more than the regular build price.
  • Changes: made for you on a care plan, usually live the same week. We don't give you a dashboard to edit, which is a trade-off we explain on custom vs WordPress.
  • Who builds it: we're a small, hands-on studio. You work directly with the person who designs and builds your site. More on who we are.

We're not the right fit for everyone. If you want to edit the site yourself every day, or you need a large online store, we'll say so on the call. We work with businesses across the west metro and central Minnesota, from Otsego and Elk River to Buffalo. See how we approach a build on our web design page, or bring your questions to a free call.

Want a straight answer for your business?

Every Stonekept build is custom-coded, hosted on Cloudflare and kept on a monthly plan. Prices are public: builds from $2,200 with care from $199/mo. See pricing or tell us about your project and we'll give you an honest read, even if that's not us.

Questions

Quick
answers.

What should I ask a web designer before hiring them?

Start with: if I cancel, does my website stay online, and do I get the files? Then ask whose name the domain is in, where the site is hosted, what the full price includes, what a change costs after launch, how long the contract runs, who writes the content, and whether you can speak to two past clients. Get the answers in writing.

Should my web designer own my domain?

No. The domain should be registered in your name, in an account you can log in to. Your designer only needs access to point it at the site. If a designer already holds your domain, ask them to transfer it to you. It costs little and protects everything else.

What happens to my website if my web designer goes out of business?

If you own the domain and have a copy of the site files, another designer can put it back online quickly. If the designer held the domain and the hosting, it can take weeks to recover, or you may have to rebuild. That's why ownership belongs in the contract before you start.

Is it normal to pay a deposit for a website?

Yes. Most designers take part of the fee upfront, commonly half. We take 50% to start and the rest at launch, and if you don't like the design direction we show you before the balance is due, the deposit is refunded in full.

What contract terms should I avoid with a web designer?

Watch for the site coming down when you cancel, multi-year terms that renew automatically, the domain registered in the designer's name, hourly changes with no estimate, no way to export the site, and wording that says the designer owns your site's design. None is always a dealbreaker, but each needs a clear answer.

Let's build something lasting

Ask us every
question on the list.

Tell us what you need and we'll map out the right approach on a free discovery call.

StudioBuffalo, Minnesota
ServingTwin Cities west metro