The short answer
If you're starting out, have more time than money and need a handful of pages, a builder like Wix or Squarespace is a sensible choice, and plenty of businesses run on one for years. If you publish a lot of content, have someone in-house who likes the technical side, or need a specific plugin, WordPress is hard to beat. If you want a fast site you own outright and would rather someone else make the changes, custom code is worth the higher upfront price. That last one is what we build, so read our reasons with that in mind and check the math yourself.
The four options differ most on five things:
- Ownership. Whether you can pick the site up and move it, or only your words and photos.
- Speed. How much of it is in your control, and how much is the platform's.
- SEO. Less different than people think. All four can rank. The work matters more than the tool.
- Who does the work. You, someone you hire by the hour, or a studio on a monthly plan.
- Cost over three years. Not the upfront price, which is the number that misleads people most.
What each option actually is
"WordPress" means two different things, and "custom" gets used loosely, so it's worth being precise.
Wix
A hosted website builder. You pick a template, drag things around the page, and Wix runs the hosting. Paid plans start at $17 a month billed yearly, checked November 2026. Light does not list online payments; Core and up add payments, ecommerce and scheduling. There's a big app market for adding features, and many apps carry their own monthly fee.
Squarespace
Also a hosted builder, with a more structured editor than Wix's free-form one and templates built around big images. Plans run $19 to $99 a month billed yearly, or $25 to $139 paid monthly. Basic carries a 2% fee on online store sales; Core and up do not.
WordPress.com
A hosted service that runs WordPress for you, so you get the WordPress editor without managing a server. Paid plans are $5 to $50 a month at renewal, with a lower first-year price. The free plan shows WordPress.com ads to visitors.
Self-hosted WordPress
The free, open-source WordPress software installed on hosting you rent yourself. This is what most designers mean when they say "we build in WordPress." You get full control, thousands of themes and plugins, and the job of keeping all of it updated. The software is free; the hosting, premium plugins and upkeep are not.
Custom code
A site written by hand for your business, with no builder or content system underneath. Ours are plain HTML and CSS, served as static files from Cloudflare's network, with no database or admin login. Other studios build custom sites in other ways, so ask what "custom" means on any quote. The trade-off with ours: there's no editor to log in to. You tell us the change and we make it.

Ownership: what you can take with you
This is the difference people find out about too late. Every platform lets you own your words and photos. Far fewer let you own the site: the pages, the layout, the thing you'd move to another host if you wanted to.
| Where the site can run | What you can take with you | The domain | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wix | On Wix only | Your words and photos, copied out by you. The site itself stays on Wix. | Yours if registered in your name, wherever you bought it |
| Squarespace | On Squarespace only | An .xml export meant for WordPress, covering some content. Store pages, portfolios and the design do not come with it. | Yours if registered in your name |
| WordPress.com | On WordPress.com, or moved to any WordPress host | Your content, exportable to another WordPress install | Yours if registered in your name |
| Self-hosted WordPress | Any host that runs WordPress | Everything: files, database, theme and plugins | Yours if registered in your name |
| Custom code | Any web host, since it's plain files | Everything, if your contract says the files are yours | Yours if registered in your name |
Squarespace export details are from Squarespace’s own help article on exporting, checked November 2026. The domain column is the same for every platform on purpose: who holds the domain is a separate question from where the site runs. Our domain, hosting and email ownership guide covers it.
A few plain facts behind that table:
- A Wix site runs on Wix. If you leave, you keep your domain and your content, and you build the new site fresh. Keep your own copies of your text and original photos so that's easy.
- Squarespace's export is partial, by its own description. Its help article says it exports "certain content" to an .xml file meant for WordPress, and that many features rely on the platform's own JavaScript and CSS, so some content doesn't export. Layout pages, one blog, text and image blocks and gallery pages come out. Store pages, portfolio and index pages, extra blogs, product, video and audio blocks, and headers and footers don't. Read it yourself before you count on it.
- WordPress moves. Self-hosted WordPress can be copied to any host that runs WordPress, design and all. WordPress.com content can be exported to a self-hosted install.
- Custom code moves only if you have the files. Plain HTML runs on any web host, but that's worth nothing if the designer keeps the files. Get file ownership written into the contract. Ours says the domain, content and files are yours, and if you cancel you get the files and help moving.
Does ownership matter for you? If the site is a few pages you'd happily rebuild in a weekend, not much. If it's fifty pages, years of blog posts and rankings that bring in calls, it matters a lot. Our rent vs own comparison puts numbers on it.
Speed: how much is in your hands
Speed matters for two reasons. People leave slow pages, especially on a phone, and Google uses page experience signals, including Core Web Vitals, as one of many inputs. Google's published "good" marks are the main content showing within 2.5 seconds (Largest Contentful Paint), a response to taps and clicks in 200 milliseconds or less (Interaction to Next Paint), and layout shift of 0.1 or less, measured at the 75th percentile of real visits on mobile and desktop separately.
What slows a page is the same everywhere: large images, lots of scripts and add-ons, and a server far from the visitor. Platforms differ in how much of that you control.
- Builders. The platform decides most of the code on the page. Squarespace says itself that many of its features rely on its own JavaScript and CSS. You control your images and how many apps or blocks you add, and not much else. A lean builder site with compressed photos can do fine; a busy one with many apps usually slows down.
- WordPress. Speed depends on the host, the theme and every plugin. A disciplined WordPress site on good hosting can be quick. One that has gathered plugins for years often isn't, and fixing it means removing things people rely on.
- Custom code. Nothing loads that wasn't put there on purpose, which makes fast the default. It still depends on the builder's discipline: a custom site stuffed with big images is slow too.
The honest test is to measure, not to trust anyone's claims (ours included). Run a few sites you like on each platform through our free Website Speed Test on a phone setting, and compare. More on what the numbers mean in our page speed guide, and on our approach on the speed and security page.
SEO: what the platform changes, and what it doesn't
Google doesn't rank a site higher because it's on Wix or WordPress or hand-written HTML. All four can rank well. What decides it is the same everywhere: pages that answer what people search, clear titles, a complete Google Business Profile, reviews, sites linking to you, and a page that loads properly on a phone.
Where the platform does make a difference:
- Control over the basics. All four let you set page titles, descriptions and the address of each page. Check that the plan you're on does, and that you know where the settings are.
- Structured data. The code that tells Google your business type, hours and service area. Builders add some automatically; going beyond what they offer is harder. WordPress does it with plugins. A custom site can include exactly what you need.
- Redirects. When you rename or move a page, a redirect sends people and Google to the new one. Every option supports them in some form. You'll need them the day you change platforms, so it's worth knowing how they work on yours.
- Speed and stability. Covered above. It's one signal among many, not a magic lever.
- Service and town pages. A service business that serves many towns often wants a page per service and per town. That's easy to start on any platform and tedious to keep consistent at scale on a builder.
If your site isn't showing up today, the platform is rarely the main reason. Start with why your business is not showing up on Google, and see what we include for search on the local SEO page. Every build we do comes with on-page SEO foundations and Google Business Profile setup. Nobody can honestly guarantee a ranking, and we don't.
Who does the work, and when
This is the question that decides most of these choices, and the one feature lists skip. A website needs work at three points: the build, the changes, and the upkeep that keeps it safe and running.
| The build | Changes after launch | Updates and security | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wix and Squarespace | You, or someone you hire | You, in the editor | The platform handles it |
| WordPress.com | You, or someone you hire | You, in the WordPress editor | Mostly the platform |
| Self-hosted WordPress | Usually a designer | You in the editor, or the designer by the hour | You or a maintenance plan: core, theme and plugin updates, backups |
| Custom code (ours) | Us | Us, on a care plan, usually the same week | Us: hosting, backups, monitoring, HTTPS |
Most builder and WordPress sites are built by the owner or a hired designer; both work. The point is to know which column you'll be standing in for the next three years.
Owners who like doing their own updates are happiest on a builder or WordPress, because the editor is right there. Owners who are busy on jobs all day often end up with a site nobody has touched in two years, whatever it's built on. For them, the nicest editor won't fix it. Someone else making the changes will.
Cost over three years, with the math
Upfront prices make builders look free and custom work look expensive. Spread over three years and including what each price actually covers, the picture is more useful. Here's every option worked out from published prices.
| Upfront | Monthly | The math | Three years | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wix Light | $0 | $17 | $17 × 36 | $612 |
| Wix Business | $0 | $39 | $39 × 36 | $1,404 |
| Squarespace Basic | $0 | $19 | $19 × 36 | $684 |
| Squarespace Core | $0 | $29 | $29 × 36 | $1,044 |
| Squarespace Core, paid monthly | $0 | $39 | $39 × 36 | $1,404 |
| WordPress.com Personal | $0 | $4, then $5 | ($4 × 12) + ($5 × 24) | $168 |
| WordPress.com Business | $0 | $25, then $28 | ($25 × 12) + ($28 × 24) | $972 |
| Self-hosted WordPress | Your time, or a designer's quote | Your host's price, plus any premium plugins | Host × 36, plus licenses, plus upkeep | Depends on your host and who maintains it |
| Stonekept Launch, then the hand-off plan | $2,200 | $79 | $2,200 + ($79 × 36) | $5,044 |
| Stonekept Launch on the 12-month term | $1,000 | $199 | $1,000 + ($199 × 36) | $8,164 |
| Stonekept Launch, month to month | $2,200 | $199 | $2,200 + ($199 × 36) | $9,364 |
| Stonekept Standard, month to month | $3,600 | $249 | $3,600 + ($249 × 36) | $12,564 |
Builder and WordPress.com prices are each company's published monthly rate, billed yearly unless the row says otherwise, checked November 2026: wix.com/plans, squarespace.com/pricing, wordpress.com/pricing. WordPress.com shows a lower first-year price that renews higher, so we used both. Add about $15 a year for a domain on any row (the builders include the first year on annual plans). Our figures are from our pricing page. Prices change, so check before you buy.
Read the table with three things in mind:
- The builder rows are the tool, not the website. They don't include your hours building it, or any paid apps. Most business sites add one or two.
- The plan you need may not be the cheapest one. Wix Light doesn't list online payments; Squarespace Basic adds a fee on store sales. Price the plan with the features you'll actually use.
- Our rows include the work. The care plan totals cover changes and new pages made for you for three years, plus hosting and monitoring. The hand-off plan covers hosting, backups, monitoring and one change a month.
Worked example
A landscaping company in Delano wants a ten-page site: home, five services, a gallery, about, reviews and contact. On Squarespace Core billed yearly that's $1,044 over three years, plus the evenings the owner spends writing and building it. On WordPress.com Business it's $972, again built by the owner. With us on the Launch plan and the 12-month term it's $8,164, and every change and seasonal update in those three years is made for them. On the hand-off plan instead it's $5,044, with one change a month.
So the builder is $7,120 cheaper than our term option over three years. If the owner would genuinely enjoy building and updating it, that's real money saved. If those evenings would otherwise go to quoting jobs, it probably isn't.
To run your own numbers for a WordPress build against ours, use the WordPress vs Custom Cost. For every other way of getting a site, including freelancers and agencies, see what a website costs in Minnesota.
Who should pick each one
No platform is right for everyone. Here's where each one genuinely wins.
Pick Wix if
- You want to build it yourself and like moving things around freely on the page.
- You need a feature from its app market quickly, like booking or simple selling on Core and up.
- It's a new venture and you want to test the idea before spending on a build.
Pick Squarespace if
- Your business sells on looks: photography, events, salons, makers, a small café.
- You want a tidy template and fewer choices to get wrong.
- You'll run a small store and can use Core or above, which has no Squarespace fee on store sales.
Pick WordPress (either kind) if
- You publish often: news, recipes, articles, a lot of blog posts that people write in-house.
- Someone on your team is comfortable with updates and plugins, or you'll pay a maintenance plan.
- You need something specific the plugin world does well, like memberships or online courses.
- WordPress.com suits you if you want WordPress without running a server. Self-hosted suits you if you want full control.
Pick custom code if
- You'd rather never touch the site and have changes made for you.
- You want a fast site you own outright, with no plugin updates or platform lock-in.
- You're a service business that needs many service and town pages kept consistent, like a contractor or home services company.
- You've outgrown a builder and want something built around how your customers actually choose you.
And when not to pick us: if you want to edit the site yourself every day, if the budget is a few hundred dollars, or if you're running a large online catalog. For that last one, Shopify is the right tool, and we cover why in Shopify vs a custom store. Our longer take on the WordPress side is on custom-coded vs WordPress.
Questions to answer before you pick
Most platform regret comes from skipping one of these at the start.
Answer these before you pick
- Who will make changes in year two, and how many hours a month can they give it?
- Does the site need anything beyond pages and a contact form: a store, bookings, a member area, a lot of blog posts?
- If you left this platform in three years, what would you take with you, and what would you rebuild?
- Is the domain registered in your name, in an account you can log in to?
- What is the full monthly bill once the apps or plugins you need are added?
- Does the site load fast on a phone over a cell connection? Test a few sites built on it.
- Can you set your own page titles, descriptions and redirects?
- Who do you call when something breaks on a Saturday?
If you're already on a builder and wondering about leaving, read moving off Wix or Squarespace first, so you keep your Google rankings through the move.
Where we fit, plainly
We build custom-coded sites for small businesses across the west metro and central Minnesota, from Delano and Buffalo to Plymouth. Builds are $2,200 to $6,400 (or $1,000 to $4,000 on a 12-month care term), then a flat monthly plan from $79. The design direction for your home page and one key inner page is signed off before the second half of the build fee is due, and if you don't like it, the deposit comes back in full.
Many sites we rebuild served their owners well for years first. DMP Awnings, for one, moved from WordPress to a custom-coded static site. See how we build, or tell us about the site and we'll say if a builder fits better.
Want a straight answer for your business?
Every Stonekept build is custom-coded, hosted on Cloudflare and kept on a monthly plan. Prices are public: builds from $2,200 with care from $199/mo. See pricing or tell us about your project and we'll give you an honest read, even if that's not us.
