Home/Guides/Shopify vs custom
Ecommerce guide

Shopify, a builder store,
or custom checkout?

If selling products online is the business, with a big catalog, variants and inventory to manage, Shopify is the right tool and we'll say so. If you sell a handful of things alongside a service, a builder store or checkout added to your own site often costs less and fits better. This guide compares all of them on published fees, works out a real month of sales, and shows which one fits which shop.

Updated November 2026 · 12 min read

Stacked cardboard shipping boxes ready to go out
Photo: Ayrat / Pexels

The short answer

It comes down to how big the store is, compared with the rest of the business.

  • If the store is the business (a real catalog, sizes and colors, stock to track, shipping rules, orders every day), use Shopify. It's built for exactly that, from $29 a month billed yearly.
  • If you sell a small range and want to build it yourself, a Squarespace or Wix store is a sensible, cheaper start. On Squarespace, pick Core ($29 a month) or above to avoid the 2% fee Basic adds on store sales.
  • If you're a service business that also sells a few things (gift cards, deposits, tickets, a short product list, donations), checkout added to your own site through Stripe or Snipcart keeps one fast site instead of two.

We build the third kind, and for the first kind we'll point you at Shopify. The rest of this guide shows the fees behind that advice.

The ways a small business can sell online

Shopify

A hosted store platform: products, variants, inventory, orders, shipping, discounts and taxes, all in one admin, with a large app market. Plans billed yearly are Basic $29, Grow $89 and Advanced $359 a month ($39, $105 and $399 paid monthly), with Plus from $2,300 a month for large brands. Card processing on Basic is 2.9% + 30¢.

Squarespace and Wix stores

The store features built into the website builders. Good for a small range of products on a site you build and run yourself. On Wix, light does not list online payments; Core and up add payments, ecommerce and scheduling. On Squarespace, basic carries a 2% fee on online store sales; Core and up do not.

Stripe on a custom site

Stripe handles the payment: the checkout page, the card, the receipt and the payout to your bank. It charges 2.9% + 30¢ per successful domestic card payment, with no setup or monthly fee. Your website sends customers to a secure Stripe checkout for each product, deposit or donation. Card details never touch your site.

Snipcart on a custom site

A shopping cart that sits on top of an ordinary website, so customers can add several items, then check out. It runs payments through a processor such as Stripe and charges its own fee on top, so check Snipcart's current pricing before you choose it. It suits a small catalog where people buy more than one thing at a time.

Shopify's Buy Button on a custom site

A middle path: products live in a Shopify account, and buttons on your own site let people buy them. You pay for the Shopify plan, and you get its inventory and order tools without moving your whole website.

Handmade wooden bowls stacked on a shop shelf
A small range of products doesn't need a big platform. A large one does. Photo: César O'neill / Pexels

When Shopify is the right tool

Shopify is built for one job, selling products, and it does it well. We recommend it, and design around it rather than against it, when most of these are true:

  • The catalog is large, or growing fast: dozens to hundreds of products.
  • Products have variants (sizes, colors, materials) with their own stock and prices.
  • Stock changes often, and someone on your team updates it themselves, daily or weekly.
  • Shipping is complicated: rates by weight or zone, several carriers, labels printed from the admin.
  • You sell in several places, online and in person, and want one stock count across them.
  • Orders are daily, so a full order admin, returns and customer accounts save real time.

For a business like that, building the same tools on a custom site would cost far more and do less. Our own ecommerce page says the same: for hundreds of products with complex inventory, Shopify is the right tool.

What to watch on Shopify: the theme and apps. A store usually adds apps for reviews, subscriptions, email and more, and each can carry its own monthly fee and add weight to the page. Price the plan with the apps you'll actually need, and test the store's speed on a phone.

Squarespace and Wix stores: a good small start

If you already have a builder site and want to sell a few products, turning on its store is the simplest step. You manage products in the same editor as your pages, and there's no second platform to learn.

Two plan details matter more than the headline price:

  • Wix: Light does not list online payments; Core and up add payments, ecommerce and scheduling. Paid plans run $17 to $159 a month billed yearly (wix.com/plans, checked November 2026).
  • Squarespace: Basic carries a 2% fee on online store sales; Core and up do not. At the sales in the worked example below, that 2% is more than the price difference between Basic and Core, so Core is the cheaper plan for any store with steady sales.

Builder stores fit when the products are few, change rarely, and you're happy to manage them yourself. They get harder when the catalog grows, and moving the store later means setting products up again; Squarespace's own export, for example, doesn't include store pages. If you're weighing the builders against each other for the whole site, see Wix vs Squarespace vs WordPress vs custom.

Stripe or Snipcart on a custom site

For a lot of small businesses, the store is a side door, not the front door. A remodeler takes design deposits. A restaurant sells gift cards. A rescue takes donations and sells a few shirts. A manufacturer sells a handful of standard parts. None of them needs a store platform; they need a few secure ways to pay on the site they already have.

That's where adding checkout to a custom site fits:

  • One site, not two. Products sit on the same fast pages as your services, with the same look and the same search setup.
  • No monthly store subscription. Stripe charges per payment, 2.9% + 30¢, with no monthly fee. Snipcart adds its own fee for the cart.
  • Security handled by the payment company. Card details are entered on Stripe's checkout, not on your site, which keeps most of the card security burden off you.
  • Good for things that aren't products: deposits, donations, monthly giving, event tickets, bookings.

And the honest limits:

  • You don't get a full store admin. Inventory, variants and shipping rules are basic or handled by hand.
  • On our sites, we make the product changes on your care plan, usually the same week. That's ideal for a range that changes a few times a year, and wrong for one that changes every day.
  • It's best under a few dozen products. Past that, or with lots of variants, Shopify starts to win.

If what you need is mostly bookings or quote requests rather than sales, read online booking and quote forms, and for donations, nonprofit donation pages.

How store fees actually add up

Every option charges some mix of four things, and comparing on the plan price alone misses most of them:

  1. The monthly plan. Shopify, Squarespace and Wix charge a subscription. Stripe has none. A custom site has its hosting and upkeep plan instead.
  2. Card processing. A percentage of each sale plus a fixed amount per order. This is usually the biggest cost once you're selling steadily, and it's similar across the options here.
  3. A platform fee on sales, on some plans. Squarespace Basic's 2% is the example in this guide.
  4. Apps and add-ons. Reviews, subscriptions, shipping tools, email. Small one at a time, real in total.

Notice that the fixed fee per order matters more for small orders. On a $10 item, 30¢ is 3% on its own. If you sell lots of low-price items, work out the fees at your real average order size.

A month of sales, worked out

Here's one month at a stated volume, using published rates. Change the numbers to your own; the method is what matters.

PlanCard processingPlatform fee on salesTotal for the month
Shopify Basic, billed yearly$29$81.60None$110.60
Shopify Basic, paid monthly$39$81.60None$120.60
Squarespace Core, billed yearly$29$81.60None on Core$110.60
Squarespace Basic, billed yearly$19$81.602%: $48.00$148.60
Wix Core, billed yearly$29Wix's own ratesCheck WixNot worked out: Wix's card rates weren't confirmed
Custom site with Stripe, on our Growth care plan$349 (the whole site, with changes made for you)$81.60None$430.60

Example volume: 40 orders a month at $60 each, so $2,400 in sales. Card processing is the percentage of sales plus the fixed amount per order. Shopify: 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic (shopify.com/pricing). Stripe: 2.9% + 30¢ for domestic cards (stripe.com/pricing). Squarespace lists card rates from the same 2.9% + 30¢ on its pricing page, and basic carries a 2% fee on online store sales; Core and up do not. All checked November 2026. Apps, themes, shipping labels and taxes are left out of every row.

Worked example

A small candle maker in Wayzata sells about 40 orders a month online, averaging $60, so $2,400 in sales. Card processing at 2.9% + 30¢ is $69.60 on the percentage plus $12.00 on the per-order amount, $81.60 in total, on Shopify, on Squarespace and on Stripe alike.

On Shopify Basic billed yearly, the month costs $110.60. On Squarespace Core it's $110.60. On Squarespace Basic, the 2% fee adds $48.00, so the cheaper plan costs $38.00 more. With checkout on a custom site on our Growth care plan it's $430.60, because that plan is the whole website, hosted, kept up and changed for you, not just the store.

For this shop, if the owner is happy running the store themselves, Shopify or Squarespace Core is clearly cheaper month to month. Our option makes sense only if the site does far more than sell candles and the owner wants every change handled.

Two things change the picture: order volume and catalog size. Card processing grows with sales on every option, so at higher volumes the plan price matters less. A bigger, busier catalog tips it further toward Shopify.

Three years, including the website

The monthly table compares the store. Over three years, it's worth comparing what you'd actually have: a store tool you run, or a whole site that's run for you.

UpfrontMonthly plan × 36Three years, before card fees
Shopify Basic, billed yearly$0, plus a theme if you buy one$29 × 36 = $1,044$1,044
Shopify Grow, billed yearly$0$89 × 36 = $3,204$3,204
Squarespace Core, billed yearly$0$29 × 36 = $1,044$1,044
Stonekept Growth on the 12-month term$4,000$349 × 36 = $12,564$16,564
Stonekept Growth, month to month$6,400$349 × 36 = $12,564$18,964

Card processing is roughly the same on every row (see the month above), so it's left out here. The platform rows are the store tool you build and run yourself; ours is the whole website, built, hosted and kept up, with product and page changes made for you. Prices checked November 2026.

Read honestly, the platforms are much cheaper if you do the work. What the higher number buys is the full website (service pages, search setup, speed, hosting, monitoring) and someone making the changes. For a pure online shop, that isn't worth it, and Shopify is the answer. For a business where selling is one part of the site, it can be. The Website ROI Calculator helps you see how many orders a site needs to bring in to pay for itself.

How to decide

If this sounds like youLook at
Hundreds of products, variants, stock that changes weekly, daily ordersShopify. We'll design around it rather than talk you out of it
A dozen products, you're building the site yourself, steady salesSquarespace Core or a Wix Core plan or above
Brand new, testing whether anyone will buyA builder store, or a Stripe payment link, before spending on a build
A service business taking deposits, selling gift cards or ticketsStripe checkout on your own site
A small range where people buy several items at onceSnipcart on your own site, or a builder store
A nonprofit taking donations and selling a little merchStripe on your own site, with monthly giving
You already run Shopify but want a faster main siteShopify's Buy Button, or Shopify for the store with a separate site

Questions to answer before you choose

  • How many products, and how many variants (sizes, colors) does each have?
  • How often do products, prices or stock change: weekly, monthly, a few times a year?
  • Who will add products and process orders, and how comfortable are they in an admin panel?
  • Do you need inventory tracking, shipping rules by weight or zone, or discount codes?
  • Do you also sell in person, or on other channels like marketplaces or social?
  • What is the full monthly cost once the apps you need are added?
  • What are the card rates, and is there an extra platform fee on each sale on this plan?
  • If you left, what product and customer data could you take with you?

How we build stores

Payments, bookings and events are part of our Growth plan: $6,400 to build (or $4,000 on a 12-month care term) and $349 a month, for 50+ core pages with priority care. We wire Stripe or Snipcart checkout into a custom-coded site served from Cloudflare's network, and sites that take payments stay on a care plan so checkout is always looked after. Smaller sites without payments start at $2,200.

One example from our own work: Rescue Network, a foster-based rescue in Buffalo, takes Stripe donations and monthly giving and runs a merch store, alongside a page for every adoptable animal. That's the kind of site where checkout added to your own site fits well. For a big catalog, we'd send you to Shopify and build the rest around it.

See ecommerce web design for what's included, or tell us what you sell. We work with shops across the west metro, from Wayzata to St. Michael, and the pricing page has every plan.

Want a straight answer for your business?

Every Stonekept build is custom-coded, hosted on Cloudflare and kept on a monthly plan. Prices are public: builds from $2,200 with care from $199/mo. See pricing or tell us about your project and we'll give you an honest read, even if that's not us.

Questions

Quick
answers.

Is Shopify worth it for a small business?

Yes, when the business is mostly the store: a real catalog, variants, stock to track and regular orders. Basic is $29 a month billed yearly (checked November 2026). If you sell only a few things alongside a service, a builder store or checkout on your own site usually costs less and fits better.

Shopify or Squarespace for a small online store?

Squarespace suits a small range on a site you build yourself; choose Core or above to avoid the 2% fee on store sales that Basic adds. Shopify suits a bigger or busier catalog, with stronger inventory, shipping and order tools. At the same sales, the monthly cost of Shopify Basic and Squarespace Core is close.

Can I sell products on my website without Shopify?

Yes. Stripe can handle checkout for each product, deposit or donation, and Snipcart adds a cart so people can buy several items at once. Both work on an ordinary website. They're best for a small range of products that doesn't change every day.

How much does Stripe charge per sale?

Stripe's standard rate is 2.9% + 30¢ per successful domestic card payment, with no setup or monthly fee (checked November 2026). International and manually entered cards cost more, so check Stripe's pricing page if you sell abroad.

Do I need to worry about PCI compliance on a small store?

Less than you might think, if card details are entered on the payment company's own checkout (Stripe, Shopify or the builder) rather than on your site. Those companies handle the card data. You still need to keep your accounts secure and follow their setup.

How many products is too many for a custom-coded store?

There's no hard line, but past a few dozen products, or with lots of sizes and colors to track, Shopify's admin starts to save more time than a custom site saves money. Daily stock changes are the clearest sign you need a store platform.

Does Stonekept build Shopify stores?

For a large catalog we'll point you to Shopify and design around it rather than talk you out of it. Our own builds add Stripe or Snipcart checkout to a custom-coded site, part of the Growth plan at $6,400 plus $349 a month.

Let's build something lasting

Sell online
on the right tool.

Tell us what you need and we'll map out the right approach on a free discovery call.

StudioBuffalo, Minnesota
ServingTwin Cities west metro